Originally Posted by James Webb 
To give a review of any artist you have to be unbiased. If you don't like that type of music to start with then you shouldn't review it. Same with all genres.
The only reason i looked you up was to see if this was your job, a music critic. Which would make this fine. But since your in a band also, i find it a bit low for a musician to give another musician a review. Let alone a damaging one.
If that was true hardly anything would get reviewed! Difference in opinion happens all the time - just look at the Oasis or Kings Of Leon reviews on here. The reviewer didn't like it and others did including myself. This review is well written and puts over what this reviewer thought of this band and I think that's fair enough. Why not do your own review of this and post it in this thread if you disagree so much with what is being said to show people another perspective but don't slag a man for his opinions. You love them, he hates them and nothing you say will change that.